Skip to content
webfixed

Guides / General

"Page with redirect" and "Not found (404)" in Search Console: when to worry

By Michael Broadbridge. Last checked 14 November 2026 on Google Search Console.

Short answer

Both are usually normal. Page with redirect lists addresses that forward elsewhere, such as http to https or old URLs you redirected, and Google indexes the destination instead. Not found (404) is fine for pages you deleted on purpose. Act when important pages return 404, your own links or sitemap point at these URLs, or redirects chain.

Symptoms

You may see one of these messages:

Page with redirect

Not found (404)

Redirect error

  • The Page indexing report lists Page with redirect or Not found (404) under Why pages aren't indexed.
  • The number of URLs in either reason grew after you moved to https, changed domain or rebuilt the site.
  • The Not found (404) list includes products or pages you deleted.
  • Some of the listed URLs are pages you expected to be in Google.

Causes, most likely first

  1. Normal redirects

    The http version of every page redirecting to https, the www version redirecting to the bare domain or the other way round, and old addresses redirected after a rebuild all show as Page with redirect. Google says redirect URLs are not indexed, only the redirect target.

  2. Pages you removed

    Deleted products, old blog posts and expired offers return 404. Google says a 404 is not necessarily a problem if the page was removed without a replacement.

  3. Your own links point at old addresses

    Menus, buttons and text links that still use an old URL send visitors and Google through a redirect, or to a page that no longer exists.

  4. The sitemap lists redirected or deleted URLs

    A sitemap should only list the addresses you want to appear in Google. Listing redirected or deleted ones sends Google to the wrong place.

  5. Redirect chains or loops

    When one redirect leads to another, and then another, Google may stop following them. These show as Redirect error rather than Page with redirect.

How to fix it

Separate the normal entries from the real problems

  1. Open the Page indexing report in Search Console.
  2. In the Why pages aren't indexed table, check the Source column. You can usually only fix reasons where it says Website.
  3. Click Page with redirect and look through the example URLs. If they are http versions, the other www version, or old addresses you redirected on purpose, there is nothing to fix.
  4. Go back and click Not found (404). Mark which URLs were deleted on purpose and which are pages that should still exist.
  5. Change the filter above the chart from All known pages to All submitted pages. URLs that still appear in either reason are listed in your sitemap.
  6. For any URL you are unsure about, paste it into the URL Inspection tool to see how Google found it and what it returned.

The example lists show up to 1,000 URLs, and changes can take a few days to reach the report.

Fix the ones that need action

  • An important page returns 404. Restore it, or if it has moved, add a permanent (301) redirect from the old address to the new one. Google recommends a 301 redirect when a page moves.
  • Your own links point at a 404 or a redirect. Update the menu, button or text link to the final address. Google recommends fixing the 404s you link to yourself or list in a sitemap.
  • The sitemap lists redirected or deleted URLs. Remove them so the sitemap only contains the final addresses. Wix and Squarespace create the sitemap automatically from your pages, so if it lists a URL that redirects or returns 404, check whether an old page with that address still exists and remove or disable it.
  • A redirect leads to another redirect. Change the first redirect to point straight to the final page. Google’s crawlers follow up to 10 redirect hops, and the Redirect error reason includes redirect chains that were too long and redirect loops.
  • A product or page was deleted and a close replacement exists. Redirect the old address to the replacement. If there is no replacement, leaving it as a 404 is fine.

Tell Google you have fixed it

  1. Fix every URL listed under the reason first. Validation stops if Google finds even one remaining instance.
  2. Open the details page for that reason and click Validate fix.
  3. Wait. Do not click Validate fix again until validation has passed or failed. Google says it typically takes up to about two weeks, and sometimes much longer.
  4. If the status shows Failed, click See details to find the URL that caused it, fix it and start a new validation.

The statuses you will see are Started, Looking good, Passed and Failed. Passed means all known instances have gone or the affected URLs are no longer available.

If that didn’t work

  1. The URL shows as Soft 404 instead

    Soft 404 means the page loads but looks to Google like an error or empty page. Google recommends returning a real 404 response for pages that truly do not exist.

  2. URL Inspection shows the old URL, not the destination

    URL Inspection reports on the exact URL you entered and does not follow the redirect. Inspect the destination URL separately to see whether it is indexed.

  3. Old URLs keep coming back

    Google says Googlebot keeps trying a 404 URL for a while, though less often over time. Links from other websites can also keep sending it there, which is normal.

When to get help

Stop and get help if important pages are missing from Google after a rebuild or domain move, if you have hundreds of old URLs that need mapping to new ones, or if you find redirect loops you cannot trace. Bulk redirects set up wrongly can send every old address to the homepage or into a loop.

What a developer would check

  • A crawl of the site for internal links that point at redirects or 404s.
  • The full redirect path for old URLs, checking for chains and loops.
  • Which URLs the sitemap lists, and whether any redirect or return 404.
  • A map of old URLs to new ones after a rebuild or platform move.

Describe the problem in your own words and WebFixed gives you an instant fixed quote. Nothing is charged until you accept it.

Related questions

Should I redirect every 404 to my homepage?
No. Redirect a removed page only when there is a close replacement. Google says a 404 is fine for a page removed without a replacement, and visitors expecting a specific product are not helped by the homepage.
Can I make Google forget an old URL?
Not permanently. Google says it keeps trying a 404 URL for a while but crawls it less often over time, and removes it from the index if it was indexed.
Is a high number of Page with redirect URLs bad?
Not on its own. Every http and www version of every page can appear there. Check that the destinations are indexed and that your own links and sitemap use the final addresses.

Written by Michael Broadbridge, Founder of Webgro. First published 14 November 2026. Last checked 14 November 2026 on Google Search Console.